Keep the C and A in Christmas.
Keep the C and A in Christmas.
Hello 2026 Christmas Party Invitee!!!
This is your one stop shop to catch up on all the action from last year’s movie “Christmas in Middle Earth: The Fellowship of the List” that you either missed (didn’t show up at party), forgot (were too inebriated), or slept through (it was too long and boring).
True Colin & AJ fans will rewatch the entire film, which you can do by clicking this link or scrolling all the way to the bottom.
Fake Colin & AJ fans will read this basic checklist and watch our nifty recap video right here:
Santa (Sauron) has this almighty Christmas list that he uses to dominate all holidays, but he got destroyed 2,000 years ago by Colin O’Brien the Mayor of Christmas (Esildur).
In modern times, Colin (Frodo) and AJ (Sam) plan an annual Christmas Party in St. Louis (the Shire).
Gandalf turns up at the 2024 edition (Supernaughty) and learns Colin’s dad Kevin (Bilbo) has Santa’s evil list.
Gandalf gets Colin and AJ to go on a quest to destroy the list in the North Pole (Mordor). Jack (Merry) and Danny (Pippin) come along.
They set out for the Valentine’s Village (Rivendell) but are hunted by Santa’s nine reindeer (the Nazgûl). Colin is stabbed by Rudolph (the Witch King of Angmar) atop the ruins of the Great Tower of Columbus Day (Weathertop).
The Mayor of Valentine’s (Elrond) revives Colin.
A council of representatives from the other holidays in Middle Earth arrive to decide what to do with the list.
They set out to destroy it and a fellowship is formed consisting of Colin, AJ, Jack, and Danny, as well as Gandalf, Aragorn and Boromir (from Christmastown), Gimli (from Halloweentown), and Legolas (I don’t think we really picked where he was from).
They go to Halloweentown (the Mines of Moria) and walk through a haunted house looking for the Mayor of Halloween. He is dead and they are attacked by trick-or-treaters (orcs).
A giant trick-or-treater (balrog) kills Gandalf.
The rest of the fellowship head to the Birthday Woods (Lothlorien) to meet with the Birthday Witch (Galadriel).
She shows Colin a terrifying vision of a future in which Santa is allowed to partner with Amazon (Sauruman) and destroy all holidays: one where Colin and AJ’s beloved party is sponsored by Pepsi and beholden to a lucrative product placement deal.
The fellowship continues on their quest, but eventually Amazon delivery drivers (Uruk-hai) catch up to them and force them to split up. They also kill Boromir, who tried to take the list from Colin.
Recap video:
Full Film: